Monday, July 7. 2008Rocksmuk album - bootleg or not?
Rocksmuk is a 1972 Dutch LP which has been of interest to many Rock'n'Roll collectors because it included not only well-known hits, but also interviews with Chuck Berry, Bo Diddley, Carl Perkins, and Jerry Lee Lewis.
For many years this interview was found only on this rare album until it surfaced on several bootleg LPs and CDs in the late 1980s and 1990s. Because the original Rocksmuk LP contained hits from the Chess and Sun labels, most collectors saw this as a bootleg as well. As such it is listed on this site and in Morten Reff's Chuck Berry International Directory. A few months ago, a Dutch reader complained about this classification: On your site I see that you call this LP a bootleg.First: Thanks, Luuk! It's always nice to get response from a reader as it shows someone is really reading your stuff. Following Luuk's comment, I went to find the Popsmuk book he was talking about. It took some months to find a seller, but finally I got it: The full title of the book is Popsmuk/Het Popjaarboek '72 by Pim Oets/Gijsbert Hanekroot, © 1972 Born nv. So this proves Luuk's first remark: The book is from 1972 and as the sticker on the cover refers to the LP, that one should be from 1972 as well. This however contradicts Fred Rothwell's statement who dates this interview to September 1973. Using the book we can correct Fred by quoting Pim Oets: "The interviews in this book have been made between September '71 and September '72 for the VARA radio program of same name [...] The sequence of the presentations is in chronological order." Given that Berry's interview is the next-to-last one, September '72 should be the best guess for the date of this interview. The book in total contains 27 portraits from Ray Charles to Paul McCartney, each consisting of some very good photos by Gijsbert Hanekroot and some three pages of interview by Pim Oets. Berry's part is an extended version of the interview heard on the album. The most interesting page in regard to the album is page 137, the next-to-last one. It contains a description of and a voucher for the Rocksmuk LP. As always, a click on this image gives you a better-readable version. So what do we learn from this ad? First we find a label for the "elpee". While the album itself does not contain any label information other than Chess and Sun, the ad calls it Negram NQCS 1. According to Discogs, Negram was a "Dutch label, which was run by Hans Kellerman. In the late seventies it changed name to Bovema Negram, which was eventually acquired by EMI Holland." Negram indeed produced Chuck Berry records in the Netherlands such as Spotlight on Chuck Berry (Chess SPLO-3) or the Dutch version of the London Sessions album (at least according to Discogs). So here's Luuk almost correct. It wasn't called Bovema back then, but it seems Negram had rights to the Berry material. Finally the ad contains a voucher on 7.50 Dutch Gulders to reduce the album price from Hfl. 17.50 to "een tientje" (ten). And it says the album is "leverbaar bij de erkende platenhandel", i.e. available in well-known record shops. Given all that, I must accept Luuk's comments: Rocksmuk is most probably a legal release.
Posted by Dietmar Rudolph
in Chuck Berry Rarities
at
12:57
| Comments (2)
| Add Comment
| Contact Webmaster
Tuesday, July 1. 2008The Chuck Berry Collector's Starter
Recently Andy McKaie of Universal complained about this site's section on recommendations: The Starter's Collection (What you must have).
I welcome critical comments, especially from Andy - because I hope he welcomes mine as well. He had two things to note: my recommendations being outdated and my selection of the most important Berry CDs being illegal. On the first topic, Andy was completely correct. I had not updated this section since 2001! Shame on me. Since then there have been several and very good compilations of Berry's work. So if my intention is to present a Starter's Collection to a fresh Berry collector, I have to present CDs which are relevant and currently on sale. Agreed! On the second topic I disagree with Andy. He complained that the two most important compilations I recommended were not from Universal/MCA, but from UK's Charly Records. Andy insists that Charly never had the rights to produce these CDs (which was decided in court). So he says these were essentially bootlegs and I should not recommend bootlegs. Yes and no. Yes, I shall not encourage you to produce or to buy bootlegged records. I create copyrighted material for a living and therefore I am very strict against bootlegging, may it be software, records, or copyrighted text such as this. Where this site shows or describes bootlegs, this is purely for documenting purposes. It is nowhere that you will find recommendations or even purchase information for unofficial releases here. The descriptions are for the collector only, showing that these items exist, usually because the legal copyright owners failed to produce the material in appropriate form. Having said that, let's continue with No: In contrast to Andy's statements, in my opinion the Charly records and CDs are not bootlegs. I do not know about Charly themselves, although I think they were under the impression to own the needed licenses. Otherwise they would not have spend such an amount of work into creating very nice and expensive CD sets. In any case I am 100% certain that record sellers as well as buyers were confident that they traded legitimate releases back then. I know I was. These items have been legally sold and can be so re-sold today. And for items such as the Bio album, the Charly CD sets are still the only way to purchase CD versions of these songs in a legally correct way. So until Universal re-releases these, I will continue to recommend getting the Charly CDs, even though this is next to impossible nowadays. In any case I have reworked the The Starter's Collection (What you must have). Enjoy and feel free to comment!
Posted by Dietmar Rudolph
in Announcements
at
16:42
| Comments (0)
| Add Comment
| Contact Webmaster
Friday, June 27. 2008Chuck Berry 1999 Interview for KMOX 1120
Today I received a CD containing a previously unreleased Chuck Berry recording!
In 1999 Bob Costas of St. Louis local radio station KMOX 1120 presented a series of Evening Specials. One of these specials was dedicated to Rock&Roll and during this special Chuck Berry gave one of his rare interviews. This interview has now been released on a CD called KMOX Classics Volume 2 - Classical Conversations. Along with the Berry interview there are various other classical conversations as the KMOX staff talks to Bill Clinton, to Cassius Clay, and many more. Chuck Berry talks about his dislikes of interviews (blaming Rolling Stone Magazine), about his life and early performances in St. Louis, about his influences (Old Blue Eyes), about him first hearing Maybellene on the radio, and about writing Roll Over Beethoven (his sister playing Bach, but that didn't rhyme). This five minute interview is very well hidden on this CD which has no track listing, no year of release, not even a company label or copyright.
Posted by Dietmar Rudolph
in LDI Sessionography - Updates
at
11:00
| Comments (0)
| Add Comment
| Contact Webmaster
Thursday, June 26. 20082120 South Michigan Avenue, Chicago, IL
Reader Eric asked what should be a simple question:
Do you know what song was first recorded at 2120 S. Michigan Ave. in Chicago? Should be easy to answer, shouldn't it? So I went through all the books I have on Chess Records to find an exact date. But none of the books tells you, when the Chess studios and office moved to this location. Spinning Blues into Gold by Nadine Cohodas is the book telling most of the story. According to Cohodas, Leonard Chess bought the property in late 1956 or early 1957. Jack Wiener, who returned to Chicago in early 1957, was given the task to build up the recording studio facilities. Chess ads used the new address in early 1957 even though the company had not yet moved in. At least during Leonard's hospitalization in Feb./March 1957 the studios were not yet functioning. Due to this, I doubt Fred Rothwell's listing who puts Berry's January 1957 session (School Day and others) already into Twenty-One Twenty. It is more likely, though, that the following Berry session was the first located there. It took place in early May 1957, probably the 6th. This corresponds to Cohodas's saying that Leonard recorded his old team Berry, Muddy Waters, Little Walter, and Howlin' Wolf first in the new studio. All of these recorded for Chess in May and June 1957. Supposing that the May 1957 session was the first one to take place on South Michigan Avenue, Rock And Roll Music would be the second song recorded there. That session started with Berry recording How You've Changed, a lesser known song which appeared first on the album One Dozen Berrys (Chess LP-1432) in March 1958.
Posted by Dietmar Rudolph
in LDI Sessionography - Q&A
at
14:17
| Comment (1)
| Add Comment
| Contact Webmaster
Saturday, June 21. 2008The Benefits of the Internet
One of the rarest official Vinyl albums containing unique Chuck Berry recordings is a Japanese concert recording named The Day of R&B. Originally released in 1982, this album contains several songs recorded by the Japanese band RC Succession, some tracks by Sam Moore of Sam & Dave fame, and two Berry recordings, all cut during a live show in Yokohama in 1982.
One reason for the rarity of this record is that in 1982 you simply did not know about strange Japanese records in Europe or in the U.S. There were a few mail order shops which sent out catalogs every half a year such as Rockhouse or Bear Family. But these catalogs contained U.S., European, and U.K. releases yet seldom Japanese ones. Even if you had found out about this Japanese album, it would have been difficult to impossible to purchase it from Japan. I remember buying once sending cash in a registered letter. Not only highly insecure, but also time-consuming with no guarantee you ever get the item you wanted. Things have changed a lot in this regard. Still it happens that you do not notice a release you might be interested in. So I found out about a Japanese re-issue of this rare Vinyl album only by reading Morten Reff's new book. The CD was released in 2005 celebrating 35 years of RC Succession. So how do you purchase a Japanese record nowadays? Through the Internet, easily. Ask Google on "The Day of R&B" CD and you'll get a list of multiple Japanese Web shops selling this item. Some even have English language text. Payment using Paypal or Credit Card is accepted world-wide. Shipping is easy, and all it takes for you is to wait two weeks until the CD arrives. Thanks, Internet! If you are looking a bit more, you will notice that using a slightly incorrect title and with no note on Berry's participation the CD is even listed at an amazon shop near you. By the way: The record number listed in Morten Reff's book is incorrect. Correct is Toshiba-EMI TOCT-11089
Posted by Dietmar Rudolph
in Chuck Berry Rarities
at
12:17
| Comments (0)
| Add Comment
| Contact Webmaster
Wednesday, June 4. 2008Two guitars on 'Johnny B. Goode'?
Reader Rick Bergemann asked to post this question for discussion. And sure it is a good(e) question:
After recently listening to "Johnny B. Goode" takes 2/3 I highly suspect that someone is playing rhythm guitar underneath Chuck's lead guitar. On take 2 Chuck abruptly stops his opening riff and shouts out for them to stop the take. The one instrument that continues on is a guitar, and it has a sound clearly distinct from Chuck's. Chuck actually has to yell several times in order to get the guitar to stop. When the guitar finally stops Chuck tells Leake to stay away from playing "Roll Over Beethoven" on the piano. In response to this the studio engineer asks Chuck if he means the piano or the guitar, at which point Chuck reiterates that he is talking about the piano. Why would the engineer ask Chuck if he was talking about the guitar if Chuck was the only guitar player? All signs point towards a second guitarist. I then listened with a renewed focus to JBG take 3 and the released version, and I thought that at some points I could make out a rhythm guitar that was clearly distinct from Chuck's. The liner notes on the new 4CD set with all 1950's recordings do not tell about a second guitarist. Fred Rothwell's book has a second guitar as being overdubbed but on the final master only. Any comments, anyone?
Posted by Dietmar Rudolph
in LDI Sessionography - Q&A
at
11:21
| Comments (10)
| Add Comment
| Contact Webmaster
Funny Rock'n'Roller Parody
Did you recently go to the movies? I usually don't. But by accident this week I got to watch Walk Hard – The Dewey Cox Story.
This 2007 movie is a complete biography of a Rock'n'Roll star – yet a fictional one. Dewey Cox as a kid learns to play the Blues, plays in a Highschool band, steps in for a famous singer and becomes a star on its own. Sex, drugs and Rock'n'Roll now guide him through his life – to prison, rehab, and comeback. The funny thing is that this biography combines everything you ever read about the rock stars' life. Dewey meets a karate Elvis. He visits the Maharishi with the Beatles. And of course he works for Jewish brothers running a record company. There's an episode on a Sonny&Cher-like TV show. His band breaks up during a many-months-long work on a new song with full orchestra (including a goat) with Dewey looking like Brian Wilson. And there's a Dylan-style folk protest concert. You have to know the common rock stars and their biographies to get most of the jokes, but if you do, this is really funny. And you may learn that Punk was invented in the late 1950s. Highly recommended! Saturday, May 31. 2008The Greatest Guitar Song of All Times
Rolling Stone Magazine today announced their selection of the "100 Greatest Guitar Songs of All Times".
And the Number One is ... Johnny B. Goode What else?!? Read the full cover story here: http://www.rollingstone.com/news/coverstory/20947527
Posted by Dietmar Rudolph
in Chuck Berry Recordings
at
18:15
| Comments (0)
| Add Comment
| Contact Webmaster
Wednesday, May 28. 2008Morten Reff's Chuck Berry Directory finally out! Part 2
I finally finished to read Morten Reff's Chuck Berry International Directory book.
I am collecting Chuck Berry music for more than 30 years now, though I never had the money or the will to collect (all of) Chuck Berry's records. While I have more than 500 Chuck Berry records and approximately the same number of CDs, I never tried to find each and every pressing or version of a record. Often the ones in my collection are cheaper re-issues. So when readers ask me about a special label or cover variant, my typical reply was that I don't know. That's no excuse any more. Morten Reff's book answers maybe not all, but most of your questions. Now we finally know that there are five different versions of the Dutch variant of Berry's On Stage album, just in case you try to collect all of them. I found it astonishing to see how much I did not know about Berry's records. I will have to rewrite some comments on this web site, probably. Morten has documented Chuck Berry's released records world-wide to a much greater extend than anyone ever before. According to his writing, the listings for the US and the UK are complete. The ones for most of Central and Northern Europe also look fairly complete to me. There's only one record documented to be published in Peru, so there may be room for extensions. If you know Chuck Berry records not yet listed in Morten's book, both Morten and I would be glad to hear from you. Some details you may be looking for you will not find in Morten's book. For instance it seems to be impossible to document all the typeface and type size differences for those records pressed in millions. Too many pressing plants, too many printers, too many variants. Morten wisely choose not to go into details here. But on the other hand you get many more details than you probably expect. For instance Morten has actually listened to all the records and therefore comments on sound quality, the use of mono, stereo, and electronically altered versions, and much more. Many, yes: many of the records Morten shows I have never seen before. And this does not only cover the more obscure Korean, Taiwanese or Philippinian releases. Even some of the Dutch or English records I have not seen before. Where available Morten has listed year of release, track listing, correct and incorrect composer credits, song variants, and more. Often he shows cover and label, including variants such as promotional copies. Best reading are his comments on the worse records such as "Nobody wants or needs this record." Volume 1 covers the officially released records. So all the more interesting ones such as bootlegs, radio station records, soundtracks, and more will be in Volume 2, due hopefully soon. There is little I don't like about this book. One thing are the images which I have two problems with: First there are too few images. Half of the records are shown visually, but the other half is not. Having helped Morten with scanning and photographing dozens of covers and labels, I know how much work is in the images shown. But especially where Morten writes about an interesting picture, I wish he would have shown it. Secondly all the images should, no: must have been in color. I know color print would have made the book more expensive. But I really doubt any buyer would care if the book would cost 40 Pounds instead of 30. Either you need this book, or you don't. I personally think color images would have made the book twice as good. Finally I miss, at least according to my wishes, some kind of pricing guide. While Morten tells about the relative rarity of an item at some places, a general value or rarity index would have been helpful. But hey, this opens an opportunity for someone to come up with a pricing guide. Let me know when you're done. Until then I cannot wait to see Volume 2. Write, Morten, write!
Posted by Dietmar Rudolph
in Chuck Berry Recordings
at
02:25
| Comments (0)
| Add Comment
| Contact Webmaster
Sunday, May 18. 2008Morten Reff's Chuck Berry Directory finally out!
I got it!
Morten Reff's new book on Chuck Berry is finally out! Yesterday I received my copy from Morten, signed and with a personal dedication. Thank you, Morten! I spent all night reading but had to stop at around page 150. And I still wasn't through the US releases chapter alone. Could you imagine you can write so much about the releases of a single artist in a single country? And Morten even omitted most of the Various Artists records and - by intention - many of the cheap CD re-issues. The Chuck Berry International Directory, Volume 1, or CBID, Vol.1 for short, lists and explains all official Chuck Berry records ever released in the US, in the UK, and in many other countries. Every record has a complete song listing and some explanation including comments on the versions included, the sound quality, and variants. For many records Morten shows cover or label, often comparing certain versions such as promos or re-issues. There is a ton of information never published anywhere else. So if you are collecting Chuck Berry records, this is THE SOURCE. Get it! Now! I will write a more detailed review within the next few weeks when I find time to do so. And I am already waiting to see Volume 2 which will cover the more obscure records such as bootlegs, radio shows, soundtracks and more. I encourage you to review Morten's descriptions and lists. If you find some omission or correction, send it to me and I will both forward it to Morten and publish it here. According to Morten, especially the listings for countries with smaller record sales might need some rework. Although the International Directory already is the best description of Chuck Berry's records ever published, help to make it even better and in the end hopefully complete!
Posted by Dietmar Rudolph
in Chuck Berry Recordings
at
10:14
| Comments (0)
| Add Comment
| Contact Webmaster
Thursday, May 15. 2008Elvis Presley Sessionography
A few weeks ago I wrote about Peter Guralnick's books on Elvis Presley. During this I said that the huge Elvis biography lacks detailed information about Elvis's recording sessions. But, I said, there are other books which fill this gap.
Several readers then wanted to know which books I had in mind and what would be the best book on Elvis's recording sessions. The one I recommend is Elvis Presley - A Life in Music, written by Ernst Jorgensen. Ernst started as a record collector and Presley fan trying to find out who played which instrument on which session and when. In later years he became Marketing Director for BMG which owns RCA Records. And finally he became the RCA man for re-releasing Elvis's recordings thus having access to all the session tapes and documents. So if not Ernst, who else would be able and willing to fully document Presley's recording history? Elvis Presley - A Life in Music is the ultimate book describing each and every recording session between 1953 and 1977. All the musicians are listed, all recorded songs whether released or not, original sources for the released versions, studio talk and much more. There is not much to add to this book and if you really want to find something to criticize, it would be that Ernst concentrates on the official RCA releases, leaving out bootlegs and such. But that's what you expect from an RCA executive. If you are listening to Elvis music, you need to have this book! Sunday, May 11. 2008How to present your Rock'n'Roll collection
Many of you will know that I regularly write for the German-language Rock'n'Roll Musik-Magazin. In October 2007 the magazine celebrated their 30th anniversary at the opening of the Bill Haley Museum in Munich, Germany. Even though I was invited, I could not participate due to business reasons. But when a business trip lead me to Munich last week, I took the opportunity and reserved some time to at least visit the museum.
So I entered a taxi (for Americans: a cab) and told the driver to take me to the Bill Haley Museum. 'To what?' he replied, 'I work as a sight-seeing guide here in Munich, but such a museum does not exist.' Well, I had the street address (Schleissheimerstr. 321) and when we got there, the taxi driver was astonished to see a large sign guiding the way to the museum. He immediately made a note of this to take guests thereto in the future. The museum opens in the afternoons only, but owner Klaus Kettner was so kind to let me in early and provided me with a private guided tour. The photo below (click to enlarge) shows Klaus Kettner (to the right) during the opening of his Bill Haley Museum, along with H.-Günther Hartig (Rock'n'Roll Musikmagazin), Bill Turner (ex Bill Haley's Comets), Mike Berry (Tribute to Buddy Holly), and Rainer Koschorz (Buddy, the musical). Photo ©2007 Rock'n'Roll Musik-Magazin used with permission Klaus is a full-time concert promoter (Rock It Concerts), record label owner (Hydra Records), and also runs the Hydra Records store in Munich. But most of all Klaus is a Rock'n'Roll fan and collector just like you and me. Having collected Bill Haley material for decades, Klaus decided to present his collection to the public. The Bill Haley Museum is located right next to the Hydra Records store. It is a 1000 sqft room stuffed with memorabilia about Bill Haley and the Comets. This indeed is a impressive collection, and all of it is professionally presented: As you would expect, there are all the original records, from the oldest 1940s releases or the most obscure Mexican albums. Among many other displays, there's a huge showcase dedicated to Rock Around the Clock alone, including records from all over the world, session details such as photos and contracts, handwritten notes, original advertising and more. You'll see tons of promotional material, autographs, songbooks, newspaper clippings, concert posters, film reels and so on - all original, of course. But besides what you and me might have in our collections in some form or another, Klaus also owns and shows Haley's Golden Records, original instruments and stage clothing, union cards, handwritten letters, awards presented to Bill Haley and much more. Many of these items you have never seen before and never will. If you ever come to Munich, take your time to visit the Bill Haley Museum! And while you are there, take a look at the Hydra Records store. I have never seen a more extensive offer of contemporary Rock'n'Roll CDs. Where other CD shops have two or five different Chuck Berry CDs in stock, Hydra Records stocks at least two dozens. These include some hard-to-find ones such as Chuck Berry meets Matchbox, His London Recordings, Deliver Me From the Days of Old, or the long out-of-stock CD version of Concerto in B. Goode. Highly recommended! Sunday, April 20. 2008Goodmann Group lets us hear some Rock'n'Roll Music
Whenever I come across an unusual Chuck Berry record, I try to find out where it stems from, what it is about and why it is special in some way. As long as Morten Reff's Chuck Berry International Directory book is not out, the only good sources for this are Fred Rothwell's book Long Distance Information and the Goldmine Promo Record & CD Guide. When both fail I ask Morten Reff for help.
But when I recently got me a new 2LP set, Morten was of no help at all. Not because he did not want to. He just did not know this record. This is the first time such happened since Morten and I started to exchange Berry information, which is a lot more than ten years by now. To be honest, the album I found is not really a Chuck Berry album in its direct sense. But it is related to Chuck Berry in many ways. First, it contains 23 Chuck Berry songs, 19 recorded by Berry himself plus 8 Berry songs recorded by other artists such as Johnny Rivers, Ronnie Hawkins, Rod Steward, Elvis Presley, or the Beach Boys. And yes I know that the math does not work, but indeed some of the songs are on this set sung twice by both Berry and some other singer. And secondly, this album's cover shows nothing more than the line "Just let me hear some of that rock'n'roll music" which as we all know is a Chuck Berry quote. The 2LP set was produced by The Goodman Group Music Publishers in 1979. The Goodman Group is a group of music publishing companies which was under supervision of Gene Goodman (brother of band leader Benny) until Marshall Chess (son of Leonard Chess) took over the business after Goodman retired. Along with the Chess Brothers, Goodman and his brother Harry in August 1953 formed Arc Music Publishing which owned and used the copyrights of all of the material coming out of Chess Records, including Berry's — and still does today. Like other publishers, the Goodman Group presented their catalogue to the industry not only in writing, but also on records such as this. "This two-record compilation contains excerpts from 100 of our most successful copyrights, along with a summary of chart activity" wrote Gene Goodman on the back of this set. And indeed there are 100 well-known songs included, all in recordings by their original artists or in famous cover versions by e.g. the Beatles or CCR. All songs come in excerpts of a minute or a half, sometimes as a combination of multiple recordings. So you hear Berry start with Back in the U.S.A. until Linda Ronstadt takes over after the first verse. It's quite funny to listen to this collage, especially because it is not in chronological but in alphabetical order (by song title). Usually the better-known versions are included, such as Rod Steward singing Sweet Little Rock And Roller instead of Berry. Sometimes the better-known versions seem to have been out of reach, such as with Around and Around which is not sung by the Stones but by Berry himself. All in all this is an interesting Berry-related item. It is probably rare as it was only produced for industry experts and never available for sale. I have not found any description of it on the Internet yet. But it's not too rare. I helped Morten to get a copy for himself and if you look around, you might be able to find one for yourself as well.
Posted by Dietmar Rudolph
in Chuck Berry Rarities
at
10:08
| Comments (0)
| Add Comment
| Contact Webmaster
Sunday, April 13. 2008Peter Guralnick on Elvis Presley
It's been a time since my last post here. There were two good reasons for my absence.
Basically I was busy. I have a business to run besides telling you about Chuck Berry's music. And this meant that while Berry was touring Europe and even performing in Germany, I was flying over the Atlantic heading the other direction multiple times doing business in the U.S. That left no time for writing articles here. The second reason I didn't have time was related to this, but also completely unrelated. Heading multiple ten-hour flights, I went to my favorite book store to purchase some books to read during the long stays on board. And while browsing the Rock Music shelves, I came across two books I wanted to read since they first appeared in 1994 and 1999 but never found the time to do so. So I purchased Peter Guralnick's extensive biography on Elvis Presley. These are two very thick books so I needed more than just the flight times. And in fact I spent many hours afterwards finishing these. And this left no time to work on this blog as well. I like Guralnick's writing since his 1971 "Feel Like Going Home" which among other things covered Chess Records in detail. This guy really knows what he is talking about. And this knowledge and detailed research can be seen on each and every page of this large two-volume work. "Last Train to Memphis — The Rise of Elvis Presley" covers Elvis's life up until September 1958, while the second volume "Careless Love — The Unmaking of Elvis Presley" starts there and continues to Elvis's death in August 1977. You need to read both and you need to have time to do so. Together they have more than 1.400 pages, depending on which edition you get. I read the German translations which are even more voluminous. If you can find them, get the hardcover bindings as this number of pages is simply too much for a paperback. What makes these two books outstanding is not their huge volume, it is their factualness. Whenever you read something about 1950's rock stars, and especially about Elvis, you are confronted with a huge pile of myths, covered by fandom. As said, Guralnick is different. Everything he writes is at least backed by facts and based on interviews with the people who were there. And where people's recollections do not match with each other or with published facts from newspapers or magazines, Guralnick tells you so. Not without reason, the books have thousands of footnotes with links to sources or additional comments. However, while staying to the facts could make a reading boring, this here is not. Guralnick is really good at telling stories. Even though you already know the end of the story, you may not want to stop reading. Well, at least I didn't. Whether you learn about Elvis's way of recording, whether you read about him making films and concert tours, or whether you wonder about how his various girlfriends and the Memphis Mafia formed his closed world, this is not boring at all. The main aspects of the book are the people. Guralnick tries to find out and explain the personalities of Gladys, Vernon, Priscilla, Col. Parker, and all the other people who basically formed the man. And he tries to look behind the curtain to show the man himself, what he said, what he did, what he thought. While the end result of such could be questionable, with Guralnick's in-depth research it is not — or at least it sounds as if not. Even such a voluminous work needs to omit things when it covers a complete lifetime of little more than 40 years. What I miss the most, especially in comparison to the contents of this site here, is the musical facts. While Guralnick writes about the recording sessions and about record releases, these comments are of very low priority. So if you are interested in when Elvis recorded Berry's "Promised Land" and how this was released, this is not the book for you. Such facts are hidden in half a sentence somewhere in between these hundreds of pages. I wish Guralnick had added a short appendix listing Elvis's records and movies, just for reference. But there are other Elvis books which fill these gaps. Also some more photographs would have been desired, especially where Guralnick writes about a special photo. In any case, this two-volume biography is one of the best books on Rock music I have ever seen! Highly recommended! Wednesday, March 19. 2008Several Discography Sections Updated
Over the last few days I updated several of the discography pages of this site. I included the new Complete 50's CD set and made some related corrections in the Chess section, changed one image in the Mercury section, and added some information to the Radio Stations section. Use the links to the right to see the corresponding sections.
You can always see the latest changes to this site using the Revisions page. This includes all additions and changes to the main pages of this site. Not included is this Blog as it is supposed to change often. Visit regularly or use the RSS feed to stay informed with the Blog contents.
« previous page
(Page 20 of 22, totaling 330 entries)
» next page
|
Main PageThis weblog is an addition to my Chuck Berry fansite called "A Collector's Guide to the Music of Chuck Berry" which describes all books and records of interest to everyone enjoying Chuck Berry's music. CategoriesWhat You MissedSome earlier but important entries:
Recent Entries
SearchCopyright and DisclaimerThe complete contents of this weblog is
© Dietmar Rudolph No part of this document may be used or published without written consent by the author. Impressum/Haftungsausschluss/Datenschutz/Disclaimer To contact the authors, email to cbguide@crlf.de. Blog AdministrationPowered by |